Maui Car Rental Prices: High Season Rates Post Columbus Day

Oct. 20, 2025. Maui car rental prices are off from last week's peak for the Columbus Day holiday but they're staying at high season levels. The biggest drop this week was for convertibles, down 61% from last week to $743/week. The best value deal i for mid-size cars at just $400/week. Expect a fall season price roller coaster.